Mindfulness, Parenting

Their stubborness, their bodies

Yesterday wasn’t the first day I was reminded that we accidentally on purpose train our daughters to give up rights to their bodies.

Even though the more mindful of us will have conversations with our young ones about ownership of their “private parts,” about “stranger danger”, about saying “No,” there is one place many of us do not let our daughters (or our male children) say when and how someone gets to touch them:

At the doctor’s office.

Or in our case, as of late, the dentist’s.

My daughter has been wary of the doctor since she was a baby — before she had the means to communicate with any body part other than her eyes. Our pediatrician at the time, a kind and aware woman in New Jersey, often joked about my daughter’s “stubborness.”

We joke about it, too.

“What does that mean?” My daughter (four years old, at the time) asked one day after being told (by me), “”You are so stubborn!”

“Stubborn means beautiful,” I would say, caught in that uncomfortable place I often find myself as a mother.  I hadn’t meant stubborn as a compliment, but I didn’t necessarily want her to know that. At that time, stubborn meant “willful” or “demanding” or “contrary.” It referred to my daughter’s insistence on pouring the milk by herself; carrying in her tiny hands the two-layered birthday cake that took an hour to ice.

But, the truth is, stubborn is beautiful, especially when it comes to our daughters. For it’s our willfulness that allows us to say, “No” when we need to.

Unfortunately, when it comes to our young daughters (let’s say under age 10), it seems that only adults get to determine when there is a true need to tell someone, “Hands off!”

When our young daughters say no — whether it is to the doctor or the dentist or the tailor trying to hem a dress — we are annoyed at them. We scold them, or punish them. What message does that send? Do we really expect them to have the courage, later, at age 12 to be able to say a firm, “Get off!” Do we really expect them to believe at age 16, “my body, my choice?”

My daughter has had a few traumatic experiences at the dentist lately. The last one was the last straw and I took her and her file out from the free dental clinic provided by our national health care system here in Israel.  I couldn’t responsibly watch my daughter in that chair anymore being told what to do and that “big girls don’t cry.”

What to do, though? My daughter needed two fillings. How could I make her get them without “making” her?

After a few days, we decided to bring her to a private dentist recommended by a friend — something not in our budget, but as I saw it, a necessity. His reputation was for being kind and gentle and good with children.

He was amazing. He treated her, even at 5 1/2 years old, like someone who was in control of her body. Someone who got to make decisions about when someone touched her and how. He told her from the moment she entered his office, “You are in control. You get to decide.” He even created this “trick” by which the mechanized toothbrush would stop spinning whenever she raised her hand up in the air. She, indeed, got to decide.

I know it’s not simple. Our kids do need to see the doctor and the dentist. There will be times when we make them do things they don’t want — get flu shots, have their ears checked, try on new shoes.

But let’s not fool ourselves, those of us who claim to be advocates for women. Let’s not pretend that we give our girls full freedom. That they make the rules about their bodies. They don’t. At least, not always. Not even in families or with doctors with the best, most progressive intentions.

We send our children, our daughters, very mixed messages.

The straight message: Force is force. Whether it’s in the dorm room or at the dentist.

Is there a way to be more mindful of this, as parents, so our children learn early on the message we want them to internalize? I think so.

I think it starts with: Stubborn is beautiful.



11 thoughts on “Their stubborness, their bodies”

  1. This is the crossroad we, as parents, all come to . As a parent to a boy I was very aware of this. Before we moved to our town (and I would have done this with any town) I checked an online list of registered child sex offenders. Because these unconscionable acts happen to both girls and boys. So, I know what you are saying, and I agree that stubborn is beautiful.

    Unfortunately there will be times when we must tell our children certain things are a necessity. Who likes going to the doctor or dentist? Not me, not my son. Today at 21, my son knows that stubborn is beautiful. And I respect his sense of self every single day.


  2. This is a thorny topic for sure. Saying “no” to a doctor or dentist has to be a different kind of “no” than to a person with bad intentions…unless that professional does not have the interest of the child in mind. Which sounds like the first dentist. There will always be kind- hearted well – intentioned people, and then…
    But I do think it’s hard for a young child to discriminate.


    1. Sheryl: It’s so hard to know though who has “bad intentions.” Even we as adults meet this challenge. I lean more towards letting the child choose, even if it means a return visit (or multiple visits).


  3. Such an interesting concept, Jen. One that I never had to deal with, perhaps because I have boys, or perhaps because my boys (usually VERY stubborn) did not put up a lot of resistance when confronted with doctors, dentists, teachers, etc. Their stubbornness and defiance only came out as it was directed toward us. We are cynical and question the intent of others by nature, and there is such a fine line between wanting your children to be strong and savvy, and submissive and wimpy. FInding a midpoint and teaching them where that is is the golden answer.


    1. Thanks for the advice Mindy. We are cynical, you are right. I wonder at what age we really develop this cynicism. I sometimes notice my own cynicism when I feel my kids are manipulating me by expressing pain or discomfort. This is another fine line: Should we assume they are telling us the truth and encourage the communication (ie. “My belly hurts” at bedtime?) Or stand firm? Man … this parenting gig is not easy.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s